Sign up for MM  |  Manage Subscriptions  |  MM Archive

Michael's Minute

About once a week, Michael writes on his companies, technology, his Broadway debut, lawsuits ... basically whatever he feels like. His aptly named "Michael's Minute" started as a forum posting back in the MP3.com days and now reaches an audience of several hundred thousand. And he really writes them all himself! Sign up here for the Michael's Minute.

When Will Microsoft, Apple and Google Do Music Lockers?

August 19th, 2010

Several of the technology giants companies have basic storage services but when it comes to music they are useful only for the sharing which they all allow and not as an interactive music locker. Simply displaying filenames in an alphabetical list does not make for a practical or usable music experience.

“...when it comes to music they are useful only for the sharing which they all allow...”

Music fans need to browse and search by artist, album and song title, not just filename. They want to group music in playlists. They want to sync with iTunes. They expect cover art and "sounds like" music searching which will help them find music for any mood. And they'll want to play their music back from any browser, smart phone, video device and internet radio. Here's a chart looking at a couple music locker companies and comparing them with file storage service from Apple, Google and Microsoft.


To view full-sized click here.

Music is a critically important part of your digital life and there's no question the big tech companies will eventually enter the music locker competition. Their crude alphabetical basic storage services are unusable for music. Even as a backup service they are impractical because they require loading files in one by one and retrieving them individually when software from companies like MP3tunes can load your entire library onto your new computer with a single click. Music requires a different interface so you can navigate and play your music on many devices. While I expect the big companies to slowly add these features and each time they do the press will herald it as a major accomplishment, it will be a long time before they can match dedicated music services.

--MR
michael@michaelrobertson.com

p.s. One irony is that while MP3tunes has been sued for copyright infringement by EMI Records for its music locker service, there is no sharing between users unlike storage services from Apple and others. Instead of suing MP3tunes they should be holding it out as a model for others to follow.



To discuss this topic with others, click here!

The Michael's Minute Meter
 80%
 20%
 0%
 AGREE  DISAGREE  MIXED
  
Do YOU generally agree or disagree with Michael in this week's Minute shown above?
 
I generally AGREE with Michael this week
I generally DISAGREE with Michael this week
I am MIXED or don't have an opinion either way
 

View the Michael's Minute Meter Report

When Will Microsoft, Apple and Google Do Music Lockers?
I Want The Same Power As Steve Jobs
Apple Quietly Enables Online Streaming To iPhones, iPad and iTouch
iTunes Music On Any TV (Without A Home Server!)
Making Apple And Google Play Nicely Together
Gates and Buffett Have It Wrong
Youtube Wins - MP3tunes (and Apple?) Cheer
The Crowd As Our Legal Team
I've Got Pandora Envy
The World's First Internet Boombox
Sad Saga of Floyd Landis
Measure Your Education Spending IQ
Death of Lala and the 10 Cent Web Song
A Billion Taco Vending Machines = Bigger Taco Industry
Mission Possible - Store The World's Music
The byo.fm Experiment
Why Android Will Triumph Over iPhone
Will Internet DVR Be Banned In Singapore?
Apple's Secret Cloud Strategy And Why Lala Is Critical
Here's My Mobile Number
Will Apple Bury Lala's 10 Cent Songs?
Google Acquires Gizmo5
Cloud Music On Your iPhone, iPod touch and Android Phone
EMI You Lie
What I'm Excited About
A Free Phone Line Using Google and Gizmo5
Cartoon Network Opens Door For Wave of New Business Opportunities
Sadly, Pandora Is Still Going Bankrupt
Vote for the Craziest Digital Music Ideas Ever
Legal Update on Personal Lockers
Obama OKs Network DVR And Hints At Music Locker
6 Ways To Save Money On Communication
The American Idol Winner Is....
Lala Admits To Using Network DRM
Roach Motel For Your Music (The New DRM Threat)

Copyright © 2001 - 2010. All rights reserved.